Opinions about the competition

[hassanqadir]

I am a maxima owner, and am thinking about a change. I know this is maxima forums, but being here and part of the fraternity it will be helpful to have some positive feedback:

My Location:: Northeast, Massachusetts

So i have been looking for new cars and i see following options:

Subaru STi , BMW 135i , Infiniti G37.

Maxima is not on the list because it does has a clutch. Clutch is a must for me Living in northeast, and i know RWDs can be pain in the ass, but i have heard that snow tires can make one survive.

I had bought the car last year out of state in MN. The car was in an accident but seller never told me, and even the steering wheel has not been properly repaired as its evident now after almost a year. I guess any legal course of action is out of the question, although 14K from college student was a really bad move on that ****** behalf.

Craigstlist aint much of help, perhaps ebay ??? Dealers are perhaps going to offer crap for it. Overall car looks great and runs decent too with few issues like noises on front end, and steering wheel. I feel the tranny starting to act up a little bit too....perhaps in its initial stages.

Thanks

[VTMaxima]

I always thought I would buy a new maxima but since I live in VT I have the itch for awd. I have been driving my brothers wrx and test drove an 05 sti. I think that is the direction I'm going to go in. However I will never sell my 97 maxima. I will drive her in the summer and get a subaru for winter and when ever I feel like driving it. I have spent alot of money on my maxima and plan to spend much more so I will hold on to her. I would say go with the STI.

[hassanqadir]

Your opinion is much appreciated. However, in my case, which is recent college grad, i would prefer to keep one car (one insurance) and then save up for a condo down payment Real estate is tempting provided i can find something new and attractive in good locality.

If i was to go STI its definitely going to be solo car. However, comparing the performance of STI with G37, STI is definitely more "practical". However, the interior of STi like driving a 14th century horse cart with turbo charged boxer engine Just my opinion. They seem to have improved the interior in the new 08 model, but jeeezzz, that thing is a HATCHBACK ! This is the reason in MA, the old body style is going for literally MORE MONEY than the brand new one.

Originally Posted by VTMaxima

I always thought I would buy a new maxima but since I live in VT I have the itch for awd. I have been driving my brothers wrx and test drove an 05 sti. I think that is the direction I'm going to go in. However I will never sell my 97 maxima. I will drive her in the summer and get a subaru for winter and when ever I feel like driving it. I have spent alot of money on my maxima and plan to spend much more so I will hold on to her. I would say go with the STI or maybe a Nissan suv.

[BenStoked]

not on the list because it does have a clutch

and

Clutch is a must for me

not making much sense...
If you do want a clutch, get a 6th gen manual.
if you dont, get an auto 6th gen...
or even another 5th...(based on a quick glance on where you posted recently, I assume thats what you have.
why would you need a brand new car? they only depreciate in value(I believe it's like 5K, as soon as it leaves the lot?), the car hasnt been proven yet in the long run, and, well, new cars are still just cars that arent used.

anywho, about the listed options(assuming new)
stI: station wagon. ugh.
135: fun little car.("little" may be a problem...)
g37: wow. but also, may be a little small...

[internetautomar]

STi

[hassanqadir]

Thanks for pointing out. I am slightly "out of it" when i typed it. Ill correct that. I do want a clutch, i mean i feel thats the whole fun of the car. I was looking for a new car becuase they are worry free to some extent.

But you are totally right about the depreciation. I mean worst investment. This maxima started fallign apart unexpectedly. So i signed up for this warranty thing today for about 1800 bux , with 400 downpayment plus 130 a month. Now they said, after first month i can go to get service even at any Nissan dealership. They will refund full ammount in first 60 days if i dont use it and/or not satisfied. So i figure, worth trying, AAA certified provider, and if i get my tranny and front end sorted out that would in itself take care of the warranty cost. I can always cancel it at later point ofcourse

STi = station wagon, AGREED. but still performance
I35i = FUn, definitely FUN packed in lil car with humongous ROTORS with aggresive BMW inscribed on them
G37= LUXURY !!!

HOWEVER, I35 and G37 = RWDs, you guys think they will get me fine in Winters as PRIMARY CARs , daily driving of about 80 miles both ways on interstate highways ? Again, this is ONLY if i dont get my maxima fixed in its pristine condition

Originally Posted by BenStoked

and


not making much sense...
If you do want a clutch, get a 6th gen manual.
if you dont, get an auto 6th gen...
or even another 5th...(based on a quick glance on where you posted recently, I assume thats what you have.
why would you need a brand new car? they only depreciate in value(I believe it's like 5K, as soon as it leaves the lot?), the car hasnt been proven yet in the long run, and, well, new cars are still just cars that arent used.

anywho, about the listed options(assuming new)
stI: station wagon. ugh.
135: fun little car.("little" may be a problem...)
g37: wow. but also, may be a little small...

[hassanqadir]

Trust me, i would love the STi. But, again, do you think having a professional first job out of college.... rolling into parking lot of company in STi is okay move with that roaring muscular exhaust ? i mean BMW 1 series has a deep aggresive sound, BUT its still a beamer and gets the BMW brand elegance. G37...well it speaks for itself in looks and interior

Again, any comments on RWD in snowy winter. Is it IMPOSSIBLE to drive (by impossible mean, FRUSTRATION everyday bla bla. i can imagine in deep snow, probably no chance, but on highway and mild snow ....)

Thakns

Originally Posted by internetautomar

STi

[Torgus]

g37.

[soundmike]

Originally Posted by hassanqadir

STi = station wagon, AGREED. but still performance
I35i = FUn, definitely FUN packed in lil car with humongous ROTORS with aggresive BMW inscribed on them
G37= LUXURY !!!

STi = so what if it's a hatch? You can't beat the easier to use cargo area (you'll need it now that you've graduated and can afford to purchase "larger" things, it'll also come in handy when you get the condo). Insurance will be higher though.

135i = it's a fun car, that's about it. It's nowhere near practical.

G37 = it's a coupe, if image is your thing then go ahead. But for a slightly lower price you can probably get a G35s instead. Less horsepower but performs just as well as the 3.7 (G37 is noticeably heavier).

How about the Legacy instead? It's AWD, 4 doors, great performance and can come in either a 5 spd or 6 spd stick.

[liqidvenom]

i say but the sti or a 335. 135 is a bit over priced i think

[MorpheusZero]

Spring for the 3er

[Torgus]

Originally Posted by soundmike

STi = so what if it's a hatch? You can't beat the easier to use cargo area (you'll need it now that you've graduated and can afford to purchase "larger" things, it'll also come in handy when you get the condo). Insurance will be higher though.

135i = it's a fun car, that's about it. It's nowhere near practical.

G37 = it's a coupe, if image is your thing then go ahead. But for a slightly lower price you can probably get a G35x instead. Less horsepower but performs just as well as the 3.7 (G37 is noticeably heavier).

How about the Legacy instead? It's AWD, 4 doors, great performance and can come in either a 5 spd or 6 spd stick.

a g35x and a g37 are equal performance wise???
can you prove this...my friends g35x is slower then my 03 max...

[Armelius]

I would pass on the BMW. Other two seem great.

[soundmike]

Originally Posted by Torgus

a g35x and a g37 are equal performance wise???
can you prove this...my friends g35x is slower then my 03 max...

My bad, the "x" shouldn't have been there, should have read "s". Thanks for noticing!

[Magikone69]

used M3? i like the 135 but IMO its too pricey, unless you opt for the bone stock one.

other than that, the sti is nice only in black. i seen a blue one and it just didnt do it for me, the black w/bronze rims looks sick. havent seen a silver yet. i think this would be a great choice.

i understand what you mean about image, when i was shopping for cars i looked at an srt-4 neon for 5 seconds..then i pictured how id look driving into down town with a BOV blasting and muffler less exhaust booming echoing off the building walls..and bringing my boss with me for lunch lmao. for an overall good car the sti seems like a winner esp considering where you live, the g35 is a bit more grown up and can possibly make you feel a little more comfortable where ever you decide to work.

[irish44j]

STI = new one look like a Kia. butt-ugly IMO
135i = might as well get a 335i. Pretty much the same performance, with more room and more stylish in appearance. The 135i is surprisingly heavy for such a small car.
g37 (coupe, I assume?) = no comments one way or the other. bandwagon, but should be a good car. I wouldn't get one personally, but then again I like 4 doors and the 4-door G is ugly.

What you need is a Miata

I would personally just get the 328i.....looks like a 335, still plenty quick, and alot less expensive. And gets better gas mileage.

[hassanqadir]

Any votes for Accord Coupe V6 or even Altima ? i know cars i initially asked are in diff league. Altima coupe is about 29K ish in price, and G37 and STI are about 38Kish, retail. I wonder if there are any special offers. I feel that G will hold its value better than Altima. Hondas are overpriced to begin with.

Any light on that extended warranty part about my current ride ? its nice to have no payments.


THANKS ALL for constructive opinions and no thread bashing

[Godson]

Its a shame your so dead set on having a stick, the S60T AWD is pretty nice IMO. It looks good on the image, wha could be wrong with a guy who drives a Volvo lol? 208hp,turbocharged, I like it. The T5 is even sweeter but still a trade off, its manual but FWD.

[DaveVQ]

why not the new mercedes c300? an absolutely beautiful car IMO

or an Audi A4 AWD?

[hassanqadir]

for benz, heres my stand which could be biased:

1. Price and maintainence
2. C class has good looks and all, but a class from benz is like a corolla from toyota. I would much rather get a higher end or a mid class car series from a diff manufacturer than getting something bottom of the line from maker like benz. (altho ill give benz the look of the rims, rotors and calipers)

Nothing about Altima ??? Any idea of altima coupe prices ? I am not concerned about having 4 doors at this point. Two doors would just done fine

Originally Posted by DaveVQ

why not the new mercedes c300? an absolutely beautiful car IMO

or an Audi A4 AWD?

[soundmike]

Originally Posted by irish44j

g37 (coupe, I assume?) = no comments one way or the other. bandwagon, but should be a good car. I wouldn't get one personally, but then again I like 4 doors and the 4-door G is ugly.

I take offense!

Originally Posted by hassanqadir

Nothing about Altima ??? Any idea of altima coupe prices ? I am not concerned about having 4 doors at this point. Two doors would just done fine

There are some good deals on the Altima right now, low APR, cash back and you can pretty much get it at invoice. Although, if you're wanting a coupe, i would suggest the Accord Coupe. Various reviews put it a notch up the Altima Coupe in terms of performance, finish and overall quality -- not to mention better gas mileage using only regular on the stick-equipped V6.

[hassanqadir]

yes, but i thought accord coupe is just about same of $2-3 grand less than G37 coupe. Now that would make infiniti better choice and RELATIVELY better investment.... well , now im confused because Hondas are perhaps best resale value, although i dono if G37 coupe will hold better than accord coupe.... Any idea on the numbers to compare them ?

Originally Posted by soundmike

I take offense!



There are some good deals on the Altima right now, low APR, cash back and you can pretty much get it at invoice. Although, if you're wanting a coupe, i would suggest the Accord Coupe. Various reviews put it a notch up the Altima Coupe in terms of performance, finish and overall quality -- not to mention better gas mileage using only regular on the stick-equipped V6.

[Redline Maxima]

Originally Posted by soundmike

I take offense!

i think the current G sedan is a beautiful car. the first ones were b