Fluids and LubricantsMotor oil, transmission oil, radiator fluid, power steering fluid, blinker fluid... wait, there is no blinker fluid. Technical discussion and analysis of the different lubricants we use in our cars.
Welcome to Maxima.org!
Welcome to Maxima.org,
You are currently viewing our forum as a guest, which gives you limited access
to view most discussions and access our other features. By joining our community, at no cost, you will have access to start new topics, reply to conversations, privately message other members (PM), respond to polls, upload content and access many other special features. Registration is free, fast and simple, so please join Maxima.org today!
ok so alot of guys on the toyota forums put a quart or half in the engine oil a day or 2 before changing the oil and it cleans the head and everything. so I was just wondering if anyone on here had done this with the vq30 form the 4th gens?? and if so what were the results?
and for you oil guru's do you think this is a bad idea??
That practice is an old "wives tale" and I wouldn't recommend it. People did it years ago because they said ATF had a higher detergency than motor oil did. So they would add a quart of atf to their oil and run it briefly before changing to clean the crankcase.
ATF and motor oil are different fluids obviously designed for different applications. They are not interchangeable. If you suspect you need a crankcase cleaner, use a product that is intended for that purpose.
Last edited by talkinghorse; 10-20-2008 at 08:18 PM.
wow -- THAT is some crazy-a$$ wives tale FOR SURE!!!
ATF is just that -- Auto Trans. Fluid....leave it out of your crankcase.
gr
__________________
"I never saw a wild thing feel sorry for itself. A small bird will drop frozen dead from a bough without ever having felt sorry for itself." ~D H Lawrence
nah.. actually its pretty popular among mechanics who work on older cars,.. it has a detergent in it,.. ive seen peolpe use 1qt of ATF plus 3 quarts to = a cars required 4 quarts. .ect.. and it works...do it at ur own risk though.. ive seen it stop knocking b4 too...
people have been doing that for years. I kinda agree with what someone stated above use products that are made for this purpose less your broke or the stuff is way over priced cause back in the day then they really did not have all the products we have now so you have to use what you have at the time ie like using tranny fluid it place of power steering fluid
I say do whatever you feel safe with
__________________ My Cardomain _ _Maxima runs 13.4@109
Dyno:? whp & ? wtq
Nitrous PB: 13.4@110mph
All Motor PB: 14.0@99mph
3280lb with driver, full trim, rims, spare, jack, fluids, etc & notorized proof
My poor grandmother mistakenly bought a case of ATF insted of oil and was using it to top off here leaky ford somehow it lasted over a year before the engine siezed she ended up using all but 1/2 a quart before she asked me to top it off for her and I realized it was ATF. Even tho it was full of ATF I never noticed the difference... till I changed the oil (ATF) with real motor oil which the car did not like at all cuz 2 days later the engine siezed. ATF in oil = bad things
__________________
Megan Racing Catback NWP Spacers & Block Plate DR Mod
UR Pulley Custom Short Ram Intake SSIM Timing Advance
To the OP, what car do you intend to use it on? How many miles?
I recommend Auto-RX for cleaning the engine. If you are looking for a quick way to clean the engine that is not full of sludge, try Amsoil Engine Flush.
Auto-Rx would be a much safer method of cleaning, but it will take longer to clean.
thanks for all the replys. I just switched to penzoil plat (from dino)and went on a short 500mile roadtrip and it really cleaned everything up fine. My mpg went up slightly. So I don't think I'll be trying it. I doubt it could do much harm but I really don't think I need it.
Funny.. I've been using ATF in the engine and manual tranny for years to help clean it up. There's absolutely nothing wrong with it, done correctly.
Many manual transmissions specify it instead of gear oil or motor oil.
You can not correctly perform something that is incorrect to begin with.
Your point that some manual transmissions require atf is not relevant to this issue. While some manual transmissions do specify atf, those units are specifically designed for that fluid...that's significantly different than pouring ATF into an engine.
Using ATF in the engine oil to clean the crankcase is definitely not a recommended practice. The fact that people have done it and the engines have lived-on doesn't make it right. ATF has different properties than motor oil does, and it should not be used in an engine. Contrary to popular belief, ATF does not act as a detergent. When added to engine oil, ATF simply thins the oil and will allow faster draining of the oil from the engine. Then consider what the residue left in the engine is going to do to the fresh oil added to the crankcase? Diluting it certainly isn't good.
If people maintain their engines properly, there should be no need to clean them internally. However, and there's different schools of thought on this, if it is thought an engine requires cleaning internally, a properly formulated engine flush is recommended since they contain both detergent and solvents specifically designed to remove soft deposits in an engine.
Don't monkey with non-engg solns to non-existing engg problems. If thereis sludge then it has to be dealt differently -- could be an engg ventilation flaw as seen in Toyota 3.0L engines, or just poor maintainence.
If one is on top of oil changes, this discussion is unncecessary.
_
Linear Mode
