Blue Mesa

Well guys, pulled a bit of a dumb **** move last night.While getting on the highway I managed to miss shift into 2nd instead of 4th which of course sent the revs a wee bit past redline.... I caught it fairly quick but by the time I looked down at the tach (after engaging the clutch) it was still at 7600rpm

Anyway the engine went back to idle and it drove home normally. It idles fine and there's no knocking or abnormal vibrations at idle or at part throttle. Is there anything I ought to check for to see if my VQ is toast?

MrEous

iTrader: (11)

I'd only worry about it if it ran like crap after your shenanigans or check engine light came on.
Most likely you were bouncing against the rev limiter and safe from doing any real harm.

Gizm0

iTrader: (1)

I've done it too... VQ seems to be a pretty strong engine, it didn't do any harm in my case...

Amerikaner83

iTrader: (17)

Don't make a habit of it But I agree with Jeff. You caught it quick enough and if it drove normally home and idled normally afterward you're ok

TravisCadello

Ya you'd know immediately if u did any damage lol. idk how u mistaked 2nd for 4th big difference their lol. and 7600rpm is not much above red line n its strong *** motor.

jus start checkin ur oil it is possible u messed piston rings up n may start burning oil.

Amerikaner83

iTrader: (17)

2nd and 4th are both the down side of the shifter...it's EASY to mistake them if you accidentally go too far from 5th...I've done it before on other cars I've driven.

Fakie J Farkerton

iTrader: (51)

I did one quarter mile pass in my buddies Si when I was 17.
I went from 1st to 2nd to 5th~
I owned a 4 speed at the time and didn't see that coming.
I just left it in 5th and finished the quarter mile at around 70mph.

He didn't let me have a second try.

SSJRICH

As long as you dont hear of feel anything different, you should be ok. If there is damage it will be unseen damage to the clutch or flywheel, which of course you cant check. The engine is PROBABLY fine. They are strong engines. I wouldn't be to concerned about it. I did the shift from 5th to 4th when I was trying to hit 6th...

Blue Mesa

You must have been haulin.... like say 120ish?


And it still seams to be acting normal, though Ive been taking it easy.

SSJRICH

Yes I was hauling at some speed... Its gives you that "lame" feeling. Your expecting to shift and take off, but instead your jolted back and feel like a dumbass...

spnkr2000

On a pushrod motor you'd have to check for a bent pushrod. Only thing you could have done to one of these is stretch the timing chain and smacked a valve or bent a piston rod... all very noticable. Or torched a crank bearing... or broken a valve spring. Pretty sure your fine if the things still running smooth... worst thing you did is hurt your pride

Child_uv_KoRn

iTrader: (7)

I've done this twice and it was at least 8k rpm both times. Engine was fine.

Don't slam the gears if you're not really paying attention O_O

RR5

iTrader: (6)

Send used oil sample to Blackstone and get their opinion.

Gizm0

iTrader: (1)

You do feel like a dumbass... Or at least I did... My money shift happened as I was overtaking a civic SI, I did a 3-2 instead of 3-4 and the nose dived, front tires screeched, engine screamed, driver of the civic looked at me with a WTF expression on his face... My pride got hurt that day...

Max_Gator

Rev limiter is irrelevant in this situation. This is a mechanical over-rev.

carsnwomen91

I've never ever mis shifted like that LOL Engine should be fine, my rev limiter is set at 7200 :-)

Gizm0

iTrader: (1)

Try to shift in 2nd doing 90mph and report back to tell us how high that needle went past 7200rpm...

PS: a video would be great

Amerikaner83

iTrader: (17)

chrome91

iTrader: (1)

i wouldnt worry if its running fine, ive done that ONCE before. years ago i was driving my moms old 3rd gen Prelude, i dont know how the hell i did it but i meant to go 3rd to 4th and went into 2nd. poor car had like 650,000km on it, nothing ever came of it. ran fine. a guy i know had this auto trans **** up on the highway and it went into 1st gear at like 140km/h. engine survived

ive seen this happen many times, even at work people come in saying they did the same thing. never has there been damaged caused, only 1 guy i work with said something happened once. guy in a Audi i think it was went from 5th to 2nd i believe, must have went to like 10k+ revs and blew the engine.

rev limiter doesnt do anything if you misshift like that, theres no fuel for the engine to cutoff to limit the RPM. youre going sky high

Mikel81

I did it in my max. It was my first time driving an auto in many years and I shifted it getting on the highway from 3 straight back into 2 instead of to the right for 4th. Looked down when it wouldn't move and saw I was at 7500rpms.

Max_Gator

Gemner

iTrader: (4)

^^^ Ive shifted an auto from 2nd to 1st at 70 mph so it IS possible (not computer controlled though, different car). May or may not have expelled some spark plugs from their holes locking up the tires from engine decel is an interesting experience

Blue Mesa

Lol well hey I was doing 80 when I had my little mishap and hilarious video btw.

Engine is still running fine but there's a momentary rattle now on cold starts, though my last Maxima did the same thing so thats more or less normal.

Going to change the oil in a couple hours, Ill post back on what I find (if anything).

Mikel81

Auto max shift pattern is like a maze.


In a manual, straight back would obviously be 4th. 4th in an auto maxima is to the right(see above). It was the first time driving my new car getting on the highway. I think my foot even came off the deadpedal and pressed for a ghost clutch.

Sorry, I didn't realize it was that confusing.

Gemner

iTrader: (4)

hard to believe that the TCU in a 5.5 gen would allow that shift to happen. Silly Nissan

L_U_D_I_AMaxima

iTrader: (3)

you are fine... there is a reason why the engine has rev limiter... ohh no wait your car is toasted... sell it to me for parts... I am just kidding... you didn't hurt anything... how fast were you going?

Max_Gator

It sounded like you were talking about a manual trans not auto but I got it now.

Max_Gator

You do understand that the rev limiter in our cars is a fuel cut. Thus, you can't push the gas pedal down and get past redline.

However, that fuel cut does nothing to stop a downshift over-rev. That's purely mechanical and there is nothing to stop it.