Brake Squeal with Brembo and Hawk HPS
#1
Brake Squeal with Brembo and Hawk HPS
Hello,
I installed some Brembo blanks with Hawk HPS pads on the front of my '02 GLE. Since they were installed they have made a considerable amount of noise while braking at certain levels of effort (hard or very light braking doesn't make any noise). The brakes work great and feel very reliable and smooth, but they are just very noisy. I've searched the internet and this site for possibilities and talked to several shops and I keep getting different feedback. I'd be interested in the opinions of some of the (Maxima owning) members here.
History:
1) Installed brakes with noise damping "goop" - made noise within two weeks
2) Took everything apart again- cleaned everything- and reapplied noise damping spray
3) Tried crappy shim stickers available at auto parts store- of course that did not work.
Any comments or help would be sincerely appreciated.
I installed some Brembo blanks with Hawk HPS pads on the front of my '02 GLE. Since they were installed they have made a considerable amount of noise while braking at certain levels of effort (hard or very light braking doesn't make any noise). The brakes work great and feel very reliable and smooth, but they are just very noisy. I've searched the internet and this site for possibilities and talked to several shops and I keep getting different feedback. I'd be interested in the opinions of some of the (Maxima owning) members here.
History:
1) Installed brakes with noise damping "goop" - made noise within two weeks
2) Took everything apart again- cleaned everything- and reapplied noise damping spray
3) Tried crappy shim stickers available at auto parts store- of course that did not work.
Any comments or help would be sincerely appreciated.
Last edited by duderiffic; 06-18-2008 at 02:56 PM.
#3
#5
I did the bed-in procedure per the instructions and have as I said above tried a few things to stop the noise- what are possible causes of the noise? I've heard it could be the clips from a local auto shop here and I wasn't sure if that made sense.
I am not particularly interested in replacing the pads as they weren't cheap and they were supposed to be good- however that is what many auto shops (surprise surprise) are trying to sell me.
I am not particularly interested in replacing the pads as they weren't cheap and they were supposed to be good- however that is what many auto shops (surprise surprise) are trying to sell me.
#8
OP, follow the bed-in instructions below and report back:
http://www.zeckhausen.com/bedding_in_brakes.htm
Either your installer screwed up an easy task or the bed-in was not enough. So may as well as do the easiest one first.
http://www.zeckhausen.com/bedding_in_brakes.htm
Either your installer screwed up an easy task or the bed-in was not enough. So may as well as do the easiest one first.
#9
from Hawk's website
Bed-in Instructions
1. After installing new brake pads, make 6 to 10 stops from approximately 30-35 mph applying moderate pressure.
2. Make an additional 2 to 3 hard stops from approximately 40 to 45 mph.
3. DO NOT DRAG BRAKES!
4. Allow 15 minutes for brake system to cool down.
5. After step 4 your new pads are ready for use.
Bed-in Instructions
1. After installing new brake pads, make 6 to 10 stops from approximately 30-35 mph applying moderate pressure.
2. Make an additional 2 to 3 hard stops from approximately 40 to 45 mph.
3. DO NOT DRAG BRAKES!
4. Allow 15 minutes for brake system to cool down.
5. After step 4 your new pads are ready for use.
#13
I am the installer. :P (For better or worse)
That is the exact procedure I followed- it was right on the box. Should I contact the manufacturer to see about an RMA? The level of noise is really unacceptable- and to be frank, quite humiliating.
I've taken everything apart 3 times and tried 3 different solutions to quiet the brakes and nothing is working. I guess from a fundamental standpoint I just would like to know what is causing it- (vibration, metal-on-metal, etc...)
Has anyone ever had brake noise and been able to fix it? (By tightening, replacing, or changing something?) That would be very useful information.
Thanks for your help & opinions.
That is the exact procedure I followed- it was right on the box. Should I contact the manufacturer to see about an RMA? The level of noise is really unacceptable- and to be frank, quite humiliating.
I've taken everything apart 3 times and tried 3 different solutions to quiet the brakes and nothing is working. I guess from a fundamental standpoint I just would like to know what is causing it- (vibration, metal-on-metal, etc...)
Has anyone ever had brake noise and been able to fix it? (By tightening, replacing, or changing something?) That would be very useful information.
Thanks for your help & opinions.
#14
Well here is the procedure I use which have not failed me yet.
When the pads are taken out of the box, I rub them together for a good 10 seconds to score them. Clean the rotors with rubbing alcohol to remove the grease. Thick layer of anti-squeal on the pad's backing as well the pad holder. Torque the torque member to 80 ft lbs and caliper 25 ft lbs. Then bed in process follows.
When the pads are taken out of the box, I rub them together for a good 10 seconds to score them. Clean the rotors with rubbing alcohol to remove the grease. Thick layer of anti-squeal on the pad's backing as well the pad holder. Torque the torque member to 80 ft lbs and caliper 25 ft lbs. Then bed in process follows.
#15
The "goo" isn't good enough. The pads ride in some brackets inside the caliper. These surfaces vibrate and create the high pitched squeal noise. Make sure the "ears" that the pads ride in are clean and have a dab of high temp grease. DAB = TINY AMOUNT. Also make sure the area in the caliper that these pads slide in are clean.
#16
Okay, do you recommend a brand or type of high temp grease?
When you refer to cleaning the caliper I'm guessing you're referring to the side that doesn't have the piston just the two "fingers" the hold the outside pad?
Thanks for your help.
When you refer to cleaning the caliper I'm guessing you're referring to the side that doesn't have the piston just the two "fingers" the hold the outside pad?
Thanks for your help.
Last edited by duderiffic; 04-22-2008 at 05:38 PM.
#19
I've used Hawk HPS pads with 12.6' X-drilled rotors for the last 4yrs and they have never squealed! I don't think you've installed the right SS shims with the spring loaded finger that on the back of the pad! (they snap on)
What I normally do is clean the back of the pads with MEK or acetone. Spray a decent coat of Disc Brake Quiet on the backs of the pads until it is partially dry apply the spring loaded shims and the spray another coat and let almost dry! Be sure all the adapter pad holders are clean and lubed with Hi-temp synthetic grease! Then bed the pads! If you have squeaking that means there is something (pad shim or pad holder) moving at a very hi frequency! So be sure that even your pad holders that fit onto the caliper adapters spring loaded clips are able to hold them securely. If any of the pad holders are loose (broken fingers) there's your source! Just order a hardware kit from the dealer or ABC Nissan!
What I normally do is clean the back of the pads with MEK or acetone. Spray a decent coat of Disc Brake Quiet on the backs of the pads until it is partially dry apply the spring loaded shims and the spray another coat and let almost dry! Be sure all the adapter pad holders are clean and lubed with Hi-temp synthetic grease! Then bed the pads! If you have squeaking that means there is something (pad shim or pad holder) moving at a very hi frequency! So be sure that even your pad holders that fit onto the caliper adapters spring loaded clips are able to hold them securely. If any of the pad holders are loose (broken fingers) there's your source! Just order a hardware kit from the dealer or ABC Nissan!
#20
I've used Hawk HPS pads with 12.6' X-drilled rotors for the last 4yrs and they have never squealed! I don't think you've installed the right SS shims with the spring loaded finger that on the back of the pad! (they snap on)
What I normally do is clean the back of the pads with MEK or acetone. Spray a decent coat of Disc Brake Quiet on the backs of the pads until it is partially dry apply the spring loaded shims and the spray another coat and let almost dry! Be sure all the adapter pad holders are clean and lubed with Hi-temp synthetic grease! Then bed the pads! If you have squeaking that means there is something (pad shim or pad holder) moving at a very hi frequency! So be sure that even your pad holders that fit onto the caliper adapters spring loaded clips are able to hold them securely. If any of the pad holders are loose (broken fingers) there's your source! Just order a hardware kit from the dealer or ABC Nissan!
What I normally do is clean the back of the pads with MEK or acetone. Spray a decent coat of Disc Brake Quiet on the backs of the pads until it is partially dry apply the spring loaded shims and the spray another coat and let almost dry! Be sure all the adapter pad holders are clean and lubed with Hi-temp synthetic grease! Then bed the pads! If you have squeaking that means there is something (pad shim or pad holder) moving at a very hi frequency! So be sure that even your pad holders that fit onto the caliper adapters spring loaded clips are able to hold them securely. If any of the pad holders are loose (broken fingers) there's your source! Just order a hardware kit from the dealer or ABC Nissan!
What are SS shims? I'm sorry if that is a weak question- is that something I should have bought or something that should have been in the box? The spring loaded finger is the one on the bottom of the outside pad, correct?
When you're referring to the adapter pad holders are those the clips that clip on the caliper that hold the pads?
Thanks CMax for your help- this is exactly the type of information I'm interested in- as you said- if it is squeaking there is something causing it.
#21
man i tried so much crap with my hawk pads and they still made noise.. drove me up the freakin wall.. i followed the bed in procedure on the box and they started squeaking later that night.. tried that red stuff you put on back of the pads.. that worked for a couple hours... then come time when i applied anti-squeak grease between the pad edges and the shims, i couldnt get one of the freakin pads off the caliper cause the red stuff glued it on there! that anti-squeak grease worked for a little bit.. then they started making noise again.. that whole braking ordeal pissed me off
#23
The problems w/ Hawks is so widespread and is as common as those that love the pads. Because I don't gamble, I went w/ Akebono last fall and have been very happy w/ them. I was one who debated brand of pads for a long time...i wanted great pads and zero noise and was not confident that the hawks would provide that considering all that I have read on them, even if i did follow the bed-in procedure to the T.
#25
brakes
CMax,
What are SS shims? I'm sorry if that is a weak question- is that something I should have bought or something that should have been in the box? The spring loaded finger is the one on the bottom of the outside pad, correct?
The SS(stainless steel Shims) that clip on to the back of the brake pads!
When you're referring to the adapter pad holders are those the clips that clip on the caliper that hold the pads?
Yes! They clip on to the caliper adapter and they have little fingers that hold them in place!
Thanks CMax for your help- this is exactly the type of information I'm interested in- as you said- if it is squeaking there is something causing it.
What are SS shims? I'm sorry if that is a weak question- is that something I should have bought or something that should have been in the box? The spring loaded finger is the one on the bottom of the outside pad, correct?
The SS(stainless steel Shims) that clip on to the back of the brake pads!
When you're referring to the adapter pad holders are those the clips that clip on the caliper that hold the pads?
Yes! They clip on to the caliper adapter and they have little fingers that hold them in place!
Thanks CMax for your help- this is exactly the type of information I'm interested in- as you said- if it is squeaking there is something causing it.
Last edited by CMax03; 04-24-2008 at 11:43 AM.
#26
So to answer the conditions of the rotors they were new Brembo blanks- I did not have them turned before installing - I'm not sure if that could be the source of my problems. Should I perhaps turn my rotors to see if that addresses the problem?
Cmax,
I don't believe I have those shims- should I have got those with my HPS pads or bought them separately? The pads seem to hold into the clips with relative ease- I checked each little tab on the clips and they all looked fine (however I'm not sure exactly what I'm looking for if they were failing)
MichMax,
I can't yet say I regret buying these pads since I'm not sure if what is causing the noise is my fault.
wyche,
So did you eventually just burn them and go with something else? If so, what did you buy? I get so upset some days I'm tempted to just trade the car in for something a bit quieter.
Cmax,
I don't believe I have those shims- should I have got those with my HPS pads or bought them separately? The pads seem to hold into the clips with relative ease- I checked each little tab on the clips and they all looked fine (however I'm not sure exactly what I'm looking for if they were failing)
MichMax,
I can't yet say I regret buying these pads since I'm not sure if what is causing the noise is my fault.
wyche,
So did you eventually just burn them and go with something else? If so, what did you buy? I get so upset some days I'm tempted to just trade the car in for something a bit quieter.
#29
Supporting Maxima.org Member
iTrader: (10)
Join Date: Mar 2007
Location: Torbay, NL, Canada
Posts: 391
Use your finger nail and see if the surface of the rotor has any grooves like a record. It should not have and grooves but it should have cross hatched scratches(scratches in two directions that look like a lot of X's on the rotor). If it has grooves it will make the pads move around and cause noise. You can reduce it by making a cross hatched pattern on the rotors with rough sand paper.
#30
Sorry to tell you this but... The Hawk does have a built on shim! Factory brake pads have the shim and the shim cover on all the front pads! The shim that was replaced by the built on Hawk shim had many slots cut into it, the shim cover is solid and still should be used even on the Hawk pads!
#31
#32
So to answer the conditions of the rotors they were new Brembo blanks- I did not have them turned before installing - I'm not sure if that could be the source of my problems. Should I perhaps turn my rotors to see if that addresses the problem?
Cmax,
I don't believe I have those shims- should I have got those with my HPS pads or bought them separately? The pads seem to hold into the clips with relative ease- I checked each little tab on the clips and they all looked fine (however I'm not sure exactly what I'm looking for if they were failing)
MichMax,
I can't yet say I regret buying these pads since I'm not sure if what is causing the noise is my fault.
wyche,
So did you eventually just burn them and go with something else? If so, what did you buy? I get so upset some days I'm tempted to just trade the car in for something a bit quieter.
Cmax,
I don't believe I have those shims- should I have got those with my HPS pads or bought them separately? The pads seem to hold into the clips with relative ease- I checked each little tab on the clips and they all looked fine (however I'm not sure exactly what I'm looking for if they were failing)
MichMax,
I can't yet say I regret buying these pads since I'm not sure if what is causing the noise is my fault.
wyche,
So did you eventually just burn them and go with something else? If so, what did you buy? I get so upset some days I'm tempted to just trade the car in for something a bit quieter.
No, you don't need to turn new rotors, turning only trues the surface, it has nothing to do with squeals! The clips that hold the pads on the adapter need to be checked! The way you ensure they fit tight onto the adapter is install them at the upper inverted position on the adapter and they should stay in place even if you wack the adapter with your hand! Check all 4 clips and make sure none have any broken tabs or loose fitting, bent tabs! From my experince broken tabs or loose fitting clips always make noise! The shims should have been installed on your factory pads. If the clips are placed in the inverted upper position and won't stay on ...throw it away or try to rebend the tabs to hold! If you think it's the Hawk pads put on some other brand and I'll guaruntee you'll still have your squeal! It's your brake hardware!!(clips, shims and spray on brake quiet)
Last edited by CMax03; 04-25-2008 at 01:24 AM.
#33
i just dealt with it until i traded the car in.. i need to get some new pads now, and i'm damn sure not getting hawks.. i'm thinking about the akebono pads to see how those work
Last edited by wyche89; 05-05-2008 at 05:26 PM.
#34
#35
so you drove on the new pads for a few weeks and instead of trying different pads like suggested you traded your car in? how much money did you end up loosing on that deal?
#36
spray on squeeze on:
The stuff has a couple of names "Disc Brake Quiet" and "Disc Quiet"! You can find they at any Auto part store around the Silicone sealants!
#37
maybe i just installed or bedded them wrong.. i would like to give them another chance, but i'm extremely hesitant because i DONT want to go back to noisy brakes.. but they stopped so well, and from my understanding, they stop better than any pad on the market
Last edited by wyche89; 05-06-2008 at 12:10 PM.
#38
I spray the stuff on and let it harden up a bit then I add a few layers to it repeating that process a few times. After the final coat of brake quiet I wait at least 25 min before installing them.
Last edited by crazy97; 05-06-2008 at 02:02 PM.
#39
Sorry to tell you this but... The Hawk does have a built on shim! Factory brake pads have the shim and the shim cover on all the front pads! The shim that was replaced by the built on Hawk shim had many slots cut into it, the shim cover is solid and still should be used even on the Hawk pads!
Where can I get these shims? Should they have come with my brakes? Do you know where I can find pictures? (I didn't seen them on the Hawk webpage) Do you agree that I shouldn't have groves on my disc, but rather a cross hatched pattern?
Thanks for your help CMax.