[95BLKMAX]

Dude, I'll have to agree with NJ Devils Fan, Chillin did take that RISK of buyin a product he did not see working prior to buying it.

But at the same time, even if you did uninstall it properly and all that, you sent it packaged basically with no protection. Its not a gasket for you to send in an envelope, its pretty sensitive electronics. Something like that needs to go in a box wrapped up in bubble wrap or that Styrofoam pop corn.

So really BOTH of you were negligent here. No one can prove anything, Chillin isnt sayin that you intentionally sent him a bad unit, because as far as you know, and as far as I myself know, that unit was working fine. But with little to no protection for shippin, anything could have happened to that thing, and thats you're mistake. The only fair thing to do is cut your looses and break the deal 50/50.